Planning/Development

Area Q: Q & A

Area Q Area Structure Plan: Q & A

Is the ASP Process Chart a draft or is it a finalized document?

How is data going to be collected and summarized? How will the gathered data be made available to the community?

Will current lot sizes be impacted by the ASP?

How will this plan impact my taxes? Are land taxes going to be increased?

What background does the consultant (USL) have, and have they done work similar to this before?

Explain the Area Q Visioning Workshop Information Chart . Who prepared this chart?

How will decisions be made for this Area Structure Plan? Will ratepayers be consulted as the Plan develops or will we be shown a completed ASP?

Can decisions made regarding an Area Structure Plan be appealed?

Why was the small group discussion format used for the December 14 workshop? 

What is the timeline for this ASP? If this Plan focuses on long term development of the area, why conduct a meeting now?

Given that Area Q is not a separate legal entity, and the legislative body governing land use and other development regulations for Area Q is Leduc County, what legal mechanism will be used to ensure that the preferences of Area Q residents will be represented fairly and accurately in any new legislation enacted by the County?

Describe how the Area Q Area Structure Plan (ASP) would become law.

To the extent that the ASP may differ in desired outcome with other residents of Leduc County outside Area Q, how will this difference be resolved? Who will arbitrate? What public consultation will be performed? What conflict resolution mechanisms are in place?

Exactly how will the ASP be certified as being complete, accurate and reflecting the will of the residents before it is passed to Council for codification into law? Describe the process, who makes this determination, and when.

Will the ASP expropriate any properties or remove any property-owner rights to the enjoyment and use of properties? If yes, will it or any subsequent interpretations of it include language guaranteeing that fair market value compensation be paid to the owner?

If ASP mandated development affects property values negatively (ex. sewer stations or transmission lines built on adjacent land), will the ASP include language guaranteeing fair market value compensation be paid to the owner?

To what extent is the ASP plan subject to interference from the Capital Region Board? For example, if we express a desire for no high density urban development, can we be overruled by the Board, Leduc County Council, or anyone else?

How will infrastructure be funded in the area if the ASP were to call for it? Describe the sources available.

Is the County contemplating any change to existing tax laws in order to fund the ASP? Describe any real or potential changes that Council or County staff is considering at this time.

Quantify the public input into the AQSP. Is there a minimum threshold of participation that must be met before the public is considered to be "adequately consulted"? What metrics do you collect to make this determination? Who is responsible for this determination?

Is it the intent of the Capital Region Board and/or County designated officials to increase population density in the area?

What protections will be enacted in this ASP to protect our water table from depletion and contamination by new developments?

Will the Area Q ASP require any changes to individual septic systems that exist today?

Will the ASP address existing road maintenance issues in the area?

Who is the monitoring entity that will ensure the AQSP is being adhered to by the County and any new developers in the area? How will they make this determination? What recourse will we have after the ASP passes into law, if we determine that the plan is being contradicted?



Is the ASP Process Chart a draft or is it a finalized document?

The flow chart is a tool that has been prepared by County staff in order to facilitate visualization of the process. It is a flexible document that might have to be adapted pending on the progress made, outcomes of each steps, interest of the community, and the flow of interactions.

The milestones are not dated as it is impossible to predict the length of the process before the process is actually conducted and several factors have the potential to modify the length of it. From a County perspective, we would like to have a concept put together for summer of 2012, but there is no guarantee that this will happen.


How is data going to be collected and summarized? How will the gathered data be made available to the community? 
Data will be collected from different sources and different mechanisms. The information will be summarized by the planning team and will become part of the Part A of the Area Structure Plan, which is basically the background information section. Information collected will be made available on the Area Q webpage and at the County office. It will also be possible to view the material at each event.


Will current lot sizes be impacted by the ASP?
An Area Structure Plan (ASP) doesn’t subdivide or change an existing property size. However, it will likely contain language surrounding property size for future development as the ASP must describe population density for the plan area in order to be in compliance with the Municipal Government Act (MGA). Considering that density is the relation of population per a defined area, it is unavoidable to discuss size/area of land uses.

In addition to the MGA requirement, this ASP will have to be in compliance with the Capital Region Growth Plan. Therefore, future development will have to meet certain requirement in terms of servicing and density.


How will this plan impact my taxes? Are land taxes going to be increased?
Any potential changes to your taxes will depend on market values at the time the assessments are prepared.  Zoning and land use are two factors that may impact an assessment that is used to determine your property taxes. Changes in zoning do not necessarily result in a change in taxes. Market value and land uses are the major factors in determining property taxes.


What background does the consultant (USL) have, and have they done work similar to this before?
Urban Systems Limited (USL) is a highly qualified multidisciplinary team with over 300 people that are professional and/or technicians in the fields of engineering, planning, environmental science, community enhancement, and transportation. They have worked on several projects in the Capital Region and several times with the County. To that effect, we can state that Leduc County has a standing agreement for services with them through our Public Work & Engineering (PW&E) Department. For more information on the firm, please visit their website at http://www.urban-systems.com/default.htm
 
In the event that the Area Q process requires expertises that are not available within the County or USL, staff will investigate available opportunities for this project.


Explain the Area Q Visioning Workshop Information Chart . Who prepared this chart?

The table is a sample of information that may be discussed at the workshop and in future events. The intent is that it will make people reflect on the area, their needs, and what they would like to leave as a legacy for their children. Hopefully, it will also create opportunities for people to exchange and learn.

 
How will decisions be made for this Area Structure Plan? Will ratepayers be consulted as the Plan develops or will they be shown a completed ASP?
When scenarios, ideas, and concepts are created and proposed, County staff will be looking for consensus if possible. It has been County practice to take advantage of those opportunities where the community agrees and build a vision that will be shared by most. When consensus cannot be reached, staff normally presents different options to Council for guidance and/or decision as they are the ones responsible under the Municipal Government Act to adopt planning documents.

Residents will get the chance to participate at each event and brainstorm, discuss, and exchange on all items brought forward. Different tools and mechanisms will be used to evaluate preference and positions. Also, once a draft plan is prepared, everyone having an interest in this project will have the opportunity to present to Council their opinion on the plan as a whole and/or on the specific elements of their choice. This will be done at the Public Hearing.

Bearing in mind that no plan can satisfy everyone and that the proposed process contains several opportunities to contribute toward the future of the area. We believe that this approach is fair and practical.

 
Can decisions made regarding an Area Structure Plan be appealed?
Area Structure Plans (ASP) can be amended from time to time as the community evolves and the needs change. The amendment process is a public process similar to the adoption process, whereas the Elected Officials will have to make a decision on a proposed bylaw but only after they have considered the feedback received through the public hearing process.
An area structure plan is adopted and amended by bylaw.
The Municipal Government Act does provide for application to the Court of Queen’s Bench for a declaration that a bylaw is invalid. The Act contains some related timelines concerning aspects of the bylaw adoption process. In addition, the Act limits the grounds for an application by stating that no bylaw may be challenged on the ground that it is “unreasonable”.


Why was the small group discussion format used for the December 14 workshop?
We felt that this format would enable the participants to discuss in the comfort of a small group each topic. Participants will get to know their workshop partners well and maybe even develop a special bond with a few of them. This dynamic will hopefully be extended to the entire group after each topic of discussion when we go to each group for their summary.

 
What is the timeline for this ASP? If this Plan focuses on long term development of the area, why conduct a meeting now?
There is no urgency in the process. As we had the kickoff event several weeks ago, it is only normal process to follow-up with an open house or a workshop so that we can start visioning with the community. Understanding that there is always something happening in the County and/or in the Capital Region, it is unfortunately impossible to pick times when everyone is available. In order to give as much chance as possible to stakeholders to participate, the County generally conducts several events and uses different medias to distribute the information and receive stakeholders feedback.


Given that Area Q is not a separate legal entity, and the legislative body governing land use and other development regulations for Area Q is Leduc County, what legal mechanism will be used to ensure that the preferences of Area Q residents will be represented fairly and accurately in any new legislation enacted by the County?

A public hearing, which is legally required under the Municipal Government Act (MGA), gives the opportunity for any affected parties to address Council directly about the content of the ASP. This can be done in writing or verbally at the hearing itself. The public hearing will be advertised for at least two consecutive weeks, as is required by the MGA. These advertisements will provide information about the date and time of the public hearing, as well as information on how ratepayers can submit feedback to Council. In preparation for the hearing, County staff will prepare a report with their recommendation to Council.


Describe how the Area Q Area Structure Plan (ASP) would become law.

In order to become a legal document, a plan must be adopted as a bylaw under the Municipal Government Act (MGA). This process requires that the County conducts three readings as well as a public hearing. The MGA states the advertisement requirements as well as the sequence in which everything has to happen in order to be legal.

In addition, the Area Q ASP may have to be submitted to the Capital Region Board (CRB) for approval before the County can adopt it. Once a final draft has been prepared, the County will have to evaluate the CRB regulation criteria and decide if the plan has to be submitted or not. If the plan has to go to the CRB, this will be required after 1st reading has been given. If the ASP is approved by the CRB, Council may give the bylaw third reading, and the Plan would become a legal document.


To the extent that the ASP may differ in desired outcome with other residents of Leduc County outside Area Q, how will this difference be resolved? Who will arbitrate? What public consultation will be performed? What conflict resolution mechanisms are in place?
 
It is Councils obligation to consider all information received at the public hearing and decide on the fate of the proposed plan. Council evaluates each plan on a case-by-case basis, and makes a decision which it hopes reflects the best interest of the community. It is common practice to refer the content of the public hearing to County staff in order for them to analyze all the data and provide Council with options and recommendations. However, it is important to note that Council will weigh all the information brought forward at its own discretion, and the decision to adopt or not adopt a plan is within their authority under the MGA.  


Exactly how will the ASP be certified as being complete, accurate and reflecting the will of the residents before it is passed to Council for codification into law? Describe the process, who makes this determination, and when.
 
All the comments and information received from the public, either from public consultation events or through other channels, is used by the planning team (County staff and consultant) in order to prepare the draft ASP. Once the planning team is satisfied that the content is in the best interest of the community and the County in addition to meeting the requirements of the MGA, a draft will be submitted to Council. At that point, Council will have to decide if the draft will be send to a public hearing or if amendments to the draft plan are required.

As of February 2012, the planning team is still analyzing the information gathered and will be preparing a recommendation to Council about the next step in the process.


Will the ASP expropriate any properties or remove any property-owner rights to the enjoyment and use of properties? If yes, will it or any subsequent interpretations of it include language guaranteeing that fair market value compensation be paid to the owner?

It is not anticipated that this ASP would require the expropriation of any properties. Expropriation is normally required when land is need for infrastructure or special projects and negotiations have failed. Property owner rights are regulated by the Land Use Bylaw (LUB). The LUB states which land uses are permitted, where they are allowed, and what rules have to be followed. Leduc County’s LUB is available for consultation at Leduc County Centre or on our website at www.leduc-county.com.


If ASP mandated development affects property values negatively (ex. sewer stations or transmission lines built on adjacent land), will the ASP include language guaranteeing fair market value compensation be paid to the owner? 
 
An ASP doesn’t mandate development. It sets a concept for the future and provides direction for the area to evolve. The implementation of the plan only happens as the landowners decide to launch their projects and if the County decides to undertake actions or improvement on public land. If a project is heading in the same direction as the plan, then it may be accepted, and if it isn’t heading in the same direction as the plan, then the proponent may have to apply for a plan amendment or conduct some changes to their project.


To what extent is the ASP plan subject to interference from the Capital Region Board? For example, if we express a desire for no high density urban development, can we be overruled by the Board, Leduc County Council, or anyone else?
 
The Capital Region Board regulation states that a municipality cannot adopt a plan or undertake any actions that are not in compliance with the Capital Regional Plan. Therefore Leduc County is bound, like all the other participants, to the Capital Region Plan.


How will infrastructure be funded in the area if the ASP were to call for it? Describe the sources available. 

It is County practice that developers are made responsible for paying for the infrastructure. However, other funding sources exist such as local improvement bylaw, redevelopment levy, municipal loans, etc. Until a draft plan is prepared and potential upgrades to infrastructure (roads, water, waste/storm water) are identified, funding sources have not been finalized.


Is the County contemplating any change to existing tax laws in order to fund the ASP? Describe any real or potential changes that Council or County staff is considering at this time. 

Funding of the Area Q ASP is being achieved through existing taxation, reserve, and stabilization funds. County Council has been investing in planning for several years in order to maximize land utilization, minimize land use conflict, and protect special areas. At the present time, administration doesn’t anticipate changes to the taxation laws as a result of the Area Q ASP being prepared.


Quantify the public input into the AQSP. Is there a minimum threshold of participation that must be met before the public is considered to be "adequately consulted"? What metrics do you collect to make this determination? Who is responsible for this determination?
 
There is no minimum requirement of public input during a plan process. The reality is that often very few people decide to get involved in such processes for a variety of reasons. Leduc County has been fortunate to have had steady stakeholder participation in the last few years, and it hasn’t been uncommon to see 100 or more people at a public meeting.

In order to increase public participation, the County is advertising at County Centre in our Planning & Development offices, in local newspapers and on our website at www.leduc-county.com. There is an opportunity on our website for interested persons to submit their contact information so that we can send them additional information. County staff is also hoping that those who attend public consultation events discuss it with other members of the community in order to engage them and solicit more feedback.


Is it the intent of the Capital Region Board and/or County designated officials to increase population density in the area?

The Capital Region Plan aims at increasing population density by setting density requirements at 2 dwelling units per hectare, as well as requiring the cluster-built form. The cluster-built form divides quarter sections into up to 129 lots, grouping development into a condensed area and leaving more room for natural areas. This is to increase sustainability, diminish the amount of land dedicated for country-residential per quarter section (size of lots would typically be 0.5 to 1 acre) and maximize the amount of land use for other rural purposes.


What protections will be enacted in this ASP to protect our water table from depletion and contamination by new developments?

The ASP will contain a servicing strategy for the plan which must accomplish the following:

  • Enable and support the desired growth
  • Evaluate the possibility of servicing existing development
  • Not negatively impact the existing servicing strategy

This servicing strategy will have to conform to all Acts and Regulations from each of the three levels of government. It is important to understand that the servicing strategy will be integral to the ASP, as one cannot work without the other. There is no need for infrastructure if there are no land uses, and we can’t enable land uses that we can’t service.

The ASP will also contain policies about the environment. If the water table is an important issue within the community, it will likely be inserted into the policy framework.


Will the Area Q ASP require any changes to individual septic systems that exist today?

The ASP will address existing septic systems and future servicing needs. The ASP will contain policies and objectives consistent with current legislation (Alberta Private Sewage System Standard of Practice, 2009). The Area Q ASP could contain language about changing the requirements of waste water management if there was rational behind such considerable intervention. Understanding that such measures are feasible but are very costly and complex, Council and the community would need to justify using alternative methods to deal with waste water.

Reasons to support such change could be health issues, environmental concerns or the desire to change the type of development happening in the area. For the time being, it is the responsibility of each owner to ensure that their existing system is maintained and operating as designed. If this is not the case, please contact your installer to have the system verified and any problems resolved.


Will the ASP address existing road maintenance issues in the area?

The ASP will contain language about the road infrastructure in the servicing section. In addition the implementation section could contain a strategy about how to address the issues identified and support future land use. This strategy will take shape in the planning process, as the planning team interacts with the community.


Who is the monitoring entity that will ensure the AQSP is being adhered to by the County and any new developers in the area? How will they make this determination? What recourse will we have after the ASP passes into law, if we determine that the plan is being contradicted?

An ASP is a document that the community, developers, stakeholders, County staff and Council will be using in order to evaluate and recommend future projects. Considering that plans can be amended through public process (under the MGA), in the event that the Council would consider a project that is not in compliance with the plan there would need to be a public consultation process. If stakeholders believe that the ASP is not being adhered to, they should bring their concerns to the attention of Leduc County council, as Council is ultimately responsible for making sure that the plan is implemented properly.

Area Q ASP Contact

Sylvain Losier, Manager of Long Range Planning
780-979-6178

Have a question?

Have a question about the Area Q ASP? This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

See the archive of answered questions

Contact Planning

Phone: 780-979-2113
Toll Free: 1-800-379-9052
Fax: 780-955-8866
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

101, 1101 - 5 Street
Nisku, AB
T9E 2X3




Bottom Spacer